Politicians have said the current work permit system exploits the 'already vulnerable status' of seasonal migrant workers.
The Justice and Home Affairs Minister is to commission and publish an independent review of Jerey's current work permit policy.
Deputy Beatriz Porée brought the request before the States Assembly.
The review will look into the feasibility, implications, benefits and risks of changing the policy so that permits are issued to employees rather than the employers, while keeping existing restrictions.
This should be presented to the States Assembly by December 2027.
Deputy Raluca Kovacs says they are 'worrying cases' of the consequences of tying employees to employers
She says we are seeing court cases showing the issue:
"When your right to stay depends on one employer, something changes; you don't speak up, you don't question.
"Being far from home and your loved one, you endure, not because you want to, but because you feel you have no choice.
"Call it modern slavery, call it discrimination, call it wrongdoing; however you label it, it exists."
She also wanted a roadmap on how the Employer Pays Principle - ensuring migrant workers are not charged recruitment fees or related costs - could be implemented in the island by June 2027.
This vote was tied, 22 for, and 22 against, meaning it wasn't carried.

Commonwealth Games: Nowacki into 100m breaststroke final
Channel Islands face 'physical' Poland test
Thousands expected at Havre Des Pas Festival this weekend
Price of heating oil and other fuel increase by more than half in a year
Man jailed for importing nearly £600k worth of cannabis in bumpers of his car
Baby born on Guernsey's Marine Ambulance
Drug trafficker who claimed he was the ‘Accredited Dealer' jailed
Jersey men involved in cocaine importation sentenced